Monday, February 05, 2007

From Anonymous

The "Greatest Show on Earth" is a far cry from what the Ringling Bros. and
Barnum & Bailey circus performers brought to Cricket Arena this weekend.

Viewers could maybe forgive the reduced scale of the Gold Unit circus
knowing that the larger Blue and Red Units that have been here in the past
supposedly couldn't schedule space in the Bobcats Arena. But smaller
shouldn't mean less energy and slow pacing, which were the main downfalls of
this show.

Some of the performers deserve credit. The tightrope walkers, trapeze
artists and contortionists showed off talent, no matter that there were only
a few of them instead of dozens spread across three rings.

The opening act -- a team of white horses led by a woman who also ascended
in the air on a metal ring -- was beautiful, even though it went on for too
long. And a handful of Frisbee-catching dogs were perhaps the most fun to
watch simply because they were clearly so excited to be doing their job
(i.e. playing catch).

The same couldn't be said for some of the other performers. The Bulgarian
Ikar acrobats, who looked like glorified cheerleaders in their first
jump-roping stint, half-heartedly ran from one trick to the next and ended
each with a weak pose. A skit performed by a couple suspended upside down
was interesting, but also lacked the pizzazz to be anything more than cute.

The show's lone massive elephant produced the most oohs and ahhs from the
crowd, entering with his trainer draped elegantly on his tusks. After a few
minutes of tricks, he exited with a charming wave of his trunk. Too bad this
act was so short.

For the number of veteran circus performers this show boasted, it didn't
feel as professional as it should have. Given that the cheapest tickets are
$15 (the same as the most elaborate Blue Unit show), there should at least
be a tiger, or another elephant, or ... something.

13 comments:

Bob Cline said...

A few locals drove the two hours to Charlotte to see this thinking they were seeing the normal three ring extravaganza. They are all sorely disillusioned now. I realize that Ken and Nicole can do what they want but when their customers are going home shaking their heads in disgust, that's just NOT GOOD BUSINESS SENSE at work.
Bob

Anonymous said...

From Eric:

I understand that Ken and Nicole's customers for the Red and Blue units are also going home shaking their heads in disgust.

Anonymous said...

It really is a shame to see how in such a short time they are distroying a National treasure and an American Institution. Demographics and surveys be damned. Corporate structure by college educated idiots. We know they are extremely wealthy, so downsizing would hardly be an excuse. If you put on a really great show the press and public will become aware of it. Thats the name of the game. For sure they know how to publicize this bunch of crap of all three shows and should live up to that motto "The GSOE".

They should be careful because surely there is someone waiting in the woodpile that could upset their windful profit applecart. Its happened in other cases and they are not immune.

Anonymous said...

I believe this is a mixed review
Not bad enough to scare people away from the $15 Ticket
But certainly not good enough to draw a crowd

Anonymous said...

That rope skipping is best left to
those who are good at in HIGH SCHOOL...in my time it would not be in a circus....same goes with that upside down thing...HOWEVER,
the public loved it the night I saw the show.....
almost forgot to mention...that very sorry charivari....LOL

Unknown said...

I have to take issue of the review of the RBBB Gold unit.

I think it has been very clear from the begining that the Gold unit was a scaled down show, but in my opinion the acts were excellent and the show very entertaining.

With regards to the price of the tickets we see the red or blue units at the Palace of Auburn Hills and the cheap seats are about 22.50 and the very best seats 100.00. So I think $15.00 for the cheap seats is a bargain.

I can't see that any show now days should be compared to the movie The Greatest Show On Earth, nor anything else. That was then (195 2) and this is now (2007) A ticket to the Ringling Show in 1952 was about $2.00.

I for one have never seen a show that i did not like. Past or Present.

Barry Miller

Buckles said...

This is the first I have heard that the public is forewarned that they are about to see a scaled down show.
In fact this might be a first in the 200 year History of the American Circus.

Anonymous said...

i will never believe irvin feld would have allowed any show he produced to be down-sized as has happened with Ringling. the monte carlo unit may have been a one-ring show, but it had more talent than all three Ringling units combined today. For those who go back to the johnny north days, as i understand it, concello left the tent show because he wanted to scale it down and north wanted to make it bigger. I'm as unhappy with the decline and fall of Ringling as anyone else; as much as i love the circus, i've had no desire whatsoever to see any of the ringling units for several years. At the same time, i haven't felt like i had to see any other show either. I remember driving 80 miles about two or three years ago to see a tent tent show that has a great reputation within the business and is loved by fans. For $20.00. I saw a show that ran less than 40 minutes; no elephants; one clown. Six perfomers and an announcer. With only one exception, a little girl about 10 or 12, the acts were pedestrian, everyday run-of-the-mill at best. So by no means is Ringling the only show that's disappointing. look at what dorey miller and johnny pugh put on the road a few years ago, and look at what those shows have become. the best of what we have, to be sure, but very obvious down-sizing. Nobody seems to be leveling the same kind of criticism at what's left of the shows that were so magnificent in their day. Now, fans say they miss the five rings but are happy with the better vision offered by three, we miss the huge herd of elephants but are happy with one ring. no one seems to question why the show that once offered 11 of the best trained elephants in the country now serves up two. I am certainly not trying to defend ringling. Under Kenneth feld, ringling has done more to hurt me personally than any other circus ever has. I have no love for feld's army first-of-may non-circus towner management team that couldn't have survive a week on ringling 10 years ago and even now wouldn't last a week with any other show.That said, while we, including me, are complaining about the seemingly intentional destruction of The Greatest Show On Earth, I feel we have to give Kenneth Feld a great amount of credit for the things he does well. No only has he taken the technical effects into the 21st century, his company is maintaining a breeding facility that may literally keep the Indian elephant alive in the united states and his company also is the leader in fighting to keep animals in the circus. Despite his many faullts, and despite my personal vow to never again attend a feld-produced show, Ringling, under Kenneth Feld, will probably still go down in history as doing more to save the indian elephant than anyone else in this country. The Feld orgaization is also right out front in fighting to keep animals while most other shows would just as soon give up a town as fight an animal ban. Yes, he has more money to spend on elephant conservation than anyone else in the business, and he's the only one with the money it takes to battle animal rights groups. But he could adopt the same attitude as so many other circus owners - i'm makimg my money, let somebody else worry about what will happen five years from now. As far as I know, Carson Barnes is the only other circus even trying to breed elephants. The bottom line is that Kenth Feld stands head and shoulders above anyone else in these two areas and we should at least give him credit for that.

Buckles said...

Would the use of the title "The Greatest Show on Earth" with a disclaimer (*) for one of the units be a paradox or an oxymoron?

Bob Cline said...

This is a great institution gone wrong I guess. RBBB Red or Blue has played Charlotte for many years now. Everyone that goes, goes knowing there are three rings, elephants, Jungle cats, etc.
I don't believe too many people knew what they were getting into when they went.

I've seen the Gold unit a couple times now. This edition has some very good acts. However, when you start the show with a powerful presentation by Sylvia Zerbini and then the show ends rather abruptly with a tumbling act, it just wasn't put together well. The Flying act was good, the High wire act was not excellent but not bad either. The two clowns Mitch Freddes (sp) and I've forgotten the other one did a great job. The father and son contortion act was mesmerizing and the upside down act is unique. I have only seen the house elephant acts and they went over very well.

Yes the Gold show was OK in my book but needed some revamping. Was it what all of the Charlotte area was expecting? Certainly not, and therein lies the major disappointment in a very lucrative market area.

Bob

Anonymous said...

FYI - In 1952 the Ringling show charged $1.50 for general admission with reserved seats for an additional $1.50 and $2.50, depending on where you sat. The cheaper reserves were on the back side in front of rings 1 and 3.

Anonymous said...

I just saw a photo of the "SHOWGIRLS" from 2006 RBBB on Circus News. If this does not make you cry you have no circus heart.

Anonymous said...

That photo was on Circus Fan Website. My heart didn't let my head or hands work right.